alertPlease note that the ongoing public health situation will have an effect on shipping and fulfilment for some products ordered from our webshop. Please visit our shipping page for the latest, detailed information. (Last updated July 22nd, 2020)

Can Bolt Action be historical?

Having seen this question on several fora and Facebook groups, I decided to attempt answering this question.

Bolt Action is a platoon level World War 2 game. Each unit is typically a squad, a support weapon or a vehicle. The gamer plays with real-life forces, so by definition, it is a historical game. Maybe the question should be rephrased to Can it be played historically?

Close assaulting troops in cover.

I play a lot of Bolt Action, primarily because it is what my local gamers play. I do enjoy playing the game too. The system for Bolt Action works very well, with the activating, pinning and morale systems giving an interesting alternative to the more traditional IGOUGO wargame.

Desert War action with Admiral Drax.

The mechanisms give a simple but historically plausible game. It is admittedly more of a game than a simulation and the 'buy in' both in terms of money and understanding the new system is pretty easy.

Where the issues begin are with the army lists. They are designed to give the player a maximum amount of freedom, which leaves the system open to some abuse.

When we play Bolt Action, it is generally with historically accurate forces. So 1944 British versus 1944 Germans, 1942 Desert Rats versus 1942 Italians etc. Having restrictions makes the game more fun.

The host of new theatre books and theatre selector lists have been a godsend to more historically minded players like me. The limits in these lists is what makes them more interesting and much more playable. No Stg 44's, Panthers or Panzerfausts in our desert games! We only use what equipment they had at the time.

Chaosbunker did such an excellent review on the new Campaign: The Western Desert book, that I could not do better. I will be doing a review later this week on the excellent Campaign: Battle of France book.

Bolt Action is lots of fun. I think it can more fun if played with forces based on historical orders of battle. We'll be playing 1940 France soon, paper thin armoured Panzers versus inexperienced French. Now that is going to be a new challenge! Less is more, in my book.

Thanks to Admiral Drax for use of the photos.

One thought on “Can Bolt Action be historical?”

  • Fingers Lane

    So You're a Platoon Commander! Comparing Chain of Command and Bolt Action.
    Trailape's Wargame
    A Blog dedicated to war-gaming and associated activities.
    Sunday, September 6, 2015.
    Hi Guys

    I've been meaning to do a comparison of these two rule systems for a considerable time but other things just simply get in the way, like other projects (Commissions, my ongoing La Haye Sainte project, painting 100s of Perry Miniatures, and building lots and lots of terrain,..).
    Well finally here it is.
    Now before I start I just want to say that I'm looking at the two systems through the eyes of a soldier (Artilleryman) of 33 years service (both in a pure training environment and operationally).
    Yes, I know they are both 'Games' and playability and pure enjoyment must sit at the top of the list, but some level of realism must in my opinion be evident, otherwise why not simply play Warhammer Fantasy?
    I've played about 5 games now of both systems and found both to be enjoyable and challenging.
    One system was however MORE challenging, realistic and for me personally, enjoyable.
    So let's look at each systems...
    http://trailape.blogspot.com/2015/09/so-youre-platoon-commander-comparing.html

    Reply
Leave a Reply
Post your comment

Karwansaray Publishers